Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
AP: 9b9a182f-b3ab-44a7-9f8a-a796f97e309d
Arizona Cardinals quarterback Ryan Lindley (14) walks of the field after the second half of an NFL football game against the Atlanta Falcons, Sunday, Nov. 18, 2012, in Atlanta. The Falcons won 23-19. (AP Photo/David Goldman)
Ryan Lindley was no better than John Skelton Sunday afternoon in Atlanta.

And why should he have been?

A sixth-round pick this past April, Lindley is in no way ready to lead an NFL team…on the road…against one of the best teams in the NFL.

Yet, Cardinals coach Ken Whisenhunt elected to turn to the rookie in place of Skelton with the Cardinals up 13-0 because, as he told the Arizona Cardinals Radio Network after the game, "The message this week was that we're going to make a change at different positions and the quarterback isn't exempt from that.

"If they're not making the plays -- enough plays -- to win, then you've got to look and see if the next guy can do that. That's why you have depth at positions and that's why you do that."

Whisenhunt said some throws were missed early, and this is true. Skelton came out of the gate playing about as poorly as he could, firing wide on nearly every throw and missing a wide-open Larry Fitzgerald on the first play following Matt Ryan's third interception of the day on a throw that, had it been accurate, would have given Arizona a 17-0 lead.

He was bad. But Whisenhunt had to know Lindley, playing in a regular season game for the first time in his career, would not be any better.

And he wasn't, finishing the day completing just 9-of-20 passes for 64 yards. The offense was as miserable as it's ever been with Lindley under center, and that was with a solid effort from the run game to go along with a superb defensive performance.

That the move was made in a game the Cardinals were leading should not be much of a surprise, as Skelton had completed just 2-of-7 passes at the time and was playing poorly.

One gets the feeling this decision was in the works for some time, and the coach was just waiting for the chance to get Lindley into a game.

It's a move there might be no going back from.

Kevin Kolb is not coming back next year. His salary along with his injury history and general ineffectiveness will assure that. Even when he's healthy, with a playoff run out of the question, what is there to gain from sending him back onto the field?

But Skelton, who played well enough last year to get a shot at the starting job this season, had done poorly enough this year to lead Whisenunt to look for a reason to send him to the bench.

This is a player who, while a notorious slow starter, had thrown for 306, 290 and 262 yards in his last three games.

This is a man who, according to Cardinals coaches last week, was showing marked improvement over the last few weeks.

This is the quarterback Coach Whiz chose to be his starter heading into the season, folks.

The decision seemed like a sound one at the time. Kolb was a mess in the preseason and Skelton, while not great, was better. And considering how he played last season, the Fordham product appeared to be heading in the right direction.

But he's regressed this season, and that's worrisome.

Matt Leinart, Derek Anderson, Max Hall, Kevin Kolb and now John Skelton. All younger quarterbacks, all never improved under Whisenhunt. In fact, one could argue most of them even regressed.

Whisenhunt's history with quarterbacks, save for his time with Kurt Warner, is checkered at best.

He had issues with Pittsburgh's Ben Roethlisberger. Matt Leinart didn't get along with him, either.

And with the way he's handled both Kolb and Skelton, one has to wonder how they feel about their head coach, too.

But that's purely speculation, possibly of the unfair variety.

What we do know is the Cardinals have now tried six different quarterbacks since Kurt Warner retired, and of the six, not one looks to be anything more than a backup in the NFL.

While there are no guarantees, it would seem likely the Cardinals will once again be looking for a quarterback in the offseason. It's becoming an annual ritual. It needs to stop.

Ken Whisenhunt and his staff appear unable to handle the quarterback position, bungling it so poorly that it has basically crippled what would otherwise be a pretty good football team. And whether the coaches are poor talent evaluators or simply unable to coax the best out of their passers, the fact remains the most important position in sports seems as hopeless as ever with regards to the Arizona Cardinals.

And nothing that happened Sunday did anything to change that perspective.

19 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    SpaceRig wrote...
    A bit unfair
    I think this assessment is a tad unfair. Lienart has shown that he's not NFL quality; he was literally handed a playoff team last year in Texas and lasted 6 plays. And lets not even get into Derek Anderson and his post Cardinals career. If any criticism is deserved, it's our choice in QBs. The jury is still out on Kolb in my opinion.
  • Abuse
    donsuns35 wrote...
    Time to go.....
    Whiz is the root of the problem and that root needs to be pulled. His whole offensive staff needs to go. If something isnt done now we are going to be hurting for years to come. I say promote Ray Horton to HC. Let him bring in his own staff. Were going to lose him to a head coaching job next year, lets see what he can do!!!!! Cant be worse than whiz
  • Abuse
    Lee A. wrote...
    Trade Fitz?
    Agreed that the Cards could get quite a bit in a trade for Fitz - he does carry a lot of trade equity. But, as was mentioned by Gambo earlier today, the salary cap hit to trade Fitz is huge so it won't happen. Too bad because he deserves a chance to play elsewhere for a winner and he's the Cards best chip in the trade game.
  • Abuse
    esc R. wrote...
    Whiz
    is the problem. they have built a solid D at times, but offense is patehtic. He does not have an eye for QB's and got lucky with Kurt. Everything else has been a bust. Cut your ties with these crappy QB's and build an O line and DRAFT a QB in the first rd for once. Maybe not this year, but maybe the year after that or so.
  • Abuse
    Rainex80 wrote...
    No
    To answer the initial question NO. Cannot handle the QB situation or for that matter when does it come into question Winsenhunt and staffs ability to scout offensive talent?! The o-line is at an all time low. Two high picks between Wells and Ryan Williams cant stay on the field. The best offensive weapon is Fitz from the Dennis Green era. Any signings worth anything are busts or cant stay on the field. It will be his downfall as a coach.
  • Abuse
    BLUWATR wrote...
    This idea was way over cooked.
    The idea that Lindley would come in and play better than Skelton was who's idea? Someone on that staff needs to be held accountable for that decision!if that was a "we want to see if Lindley can play" than that could have waited until the last 3 games. You could see the Falcons lick thier chops over Lindley at least the Falcons Dee was respecting what damage Skelton could do passing. That was clearly a loss that should be pinned right on coach Whiz and for that matter the season is pretty much done. We will never know but I think that game was winnable until Lindley was put in.
  • Abuse
    PhxFan1 wrote...
    WHAT A MESS!
    The Whiz era over! This team probably worse off next year, and yes it’s time to rebuild unless were ready to except 6-7 game losing streaks every year? Trade Fitz for picks, a legit contender in need of a #1 WR would probably trade a 1 and 2 for a WR in his prime. I don’t see any solid top 5 QB’s in the draft, this is probably the deepest line draft in years, TAKE ADVANTAGE CARDS! of talent, het this guy out and fill some needs!
  • Abuse
    PhxFan1 wrote...
    Cont...
    Even with a solid line draft this team will be drafting top 7 next year, get the line developed and then draft your QB. Fitz is almost ready to snap, 1 catch for 11 yards is a waste of talent, het this guy out and fill some needs!
  • Abuse
    gilbug01 wrote...
    The truth be told...
    Finally someone telling the truth about the inabilities of the coaching staff. The must be held responsible.
close

Share: