Updated Jun 23, 2013 - 9:43 am
FanBall Weekly - Puig's case for the Midsummer Classic
Yasiel Puig should be an All-Star...One word: numbers. And here's a nice chronological list of them. He hit .354 with 5 HRs in 23 games in the minors last year, a good start. During Spring Training this year, he hit .517 in 27 games. I know none of these are relevant to the voting public, but it builds the foundation for the argument and shows that his performance in the 2013 regular season isn't a fluke.
As I've written before, not every All-Star deserves a spot on the squad. It's usually a popularity contest that ends up getting Derek Jeter elected in an injury year. Though I disagree with this ideology, it still holds true. Puig is one of the most popular players in the game today. He hit four home runs in his first five games, including two in his second game. That's a very easy way to gain popularity. He has more three-hit games (four) than no-hit games (three) and scored a run on more than half of the days he's played. And the biggest number of all, after his first 18 games in the big leagues he's hitting .435. Let's compare that with last year's rookie All-Stars. I'm excusing Mike Trout's play in the 2011 season since he wasn't the "Mike Trout" we all know and love today. Through his first 18 games in 2012, he was hitting .338, true rookie Bryce Harper was hitting .227. Expected 2013 All-Star Manny Machado hit .238 in his first 18 games.
Purely based on the astronomical numbers, Yasiel Puig should be a 2013 All-Star.
Yasiel Puig should NOT be an All-Star... If you didn't think Mike Trout and Bryce Harper deserved to be All-Stars last season, then you definitely don't think Puig should be one this year. Some purists may argue that any player who doesn't open the season with a team should be eligible for the Midsummer Classic, but with stars on the DL and April and May call-ups, that argument seems void.
To counter the above point, let's take a look at some different numbers. Though Puig is getting hits, he's having much more difficulty taking walks, only taking three plus one intentional. His strikeout total is high at 16, which is to be expected from a power hitter. Since his explosion of home runs during his first week in the majors, Puig has only hit two balls out of the park, both solo homers and both the only RBIs he's tacked up after his fifth game. Does a player whose power numbers are nearly nonexistent after five games in the majors deserve to be an All-Star? I don't think so. Sure, he's getting hits left and right, he's putting the ball in play and scoring runs but certainly not at an All-Star level. The average is nice but it will drop back down once pitchers get enough film on him to work around his bat.
Based on tradition and poor secondary numbers, Yasiel Puig should not be an All-Star.
So there you have it readers, the argument for both sides. If you agree, you can write him in here as an outfielder. If you disagree, don't fill out the ballot, or click there and pick three of your own instead. I believe Puig will find his way into the All-Star Game, partly because the MLB is always starving for ratings and partly because he's hitting .435. Regardless of whatever else you've done, I believe that if you're hitting over .400 after a month's worth of games, you should absolutely be considered for the All-Star Game. Considered. Not automatically added. Either way I'm excited to watch the game and curious to see where our new Cuban friend will end up.
I love you all...except Hawk Harrelson.
- Mark Grace named D-backs minor league hitting coach
- Luis Gonzalez: Mark Trumbo a Christmas gift for Paul Goldschmidt
- Diamondbacks extend relief pitcher Brad Ziegler
- D-backs pitcher Brandon McCarthy: Protective headgear will be available in 2014
- The Pulse: 'Let's wait and see' on Addison Reed-Matt Davidson trade
- Luis Gonzalez, D-backs World Series Legend - Friday December 20Gonzo discusses the Trumbo trade and what it means for the D-backs.
- Brad Ziegler, D-backs Pitcher - Wednesday December 18D-backs trying to win now, Ziggy talks about what that means for the clubhouse.
- Tim Kurkjian, ESPN MLB analyst - Thursday December 12Did the D-backs pick up a true power hitter?
- Mark Trumbo, Diamondbacks Outfielder - Wednesday December 11Mark Trumbo joins the show to discuss being traded to the Diamondbacks.
- Kevin Towers, D-backs GM - Wednesday December 11Why did the D-backs add Mark Trumbo and will they make more moves?